| Author | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
HistoryBuff |
Back from my first reenactment! |
Lead | ||
|
I just got back from The Brooksville Raid. The only bad part was they were sort on Union Infantry so we had to play Yankees both days, but that didn't
really bother me so much. Just a little disappointed. The rest was so freakin' awesome though! I cannot wait to get back out there!
|
||||
|
|
||||
moinfantry |
#1 | |||
|
Glad to know you were fightin' for the right side. So many on here, including CC, are ardent TRAITORS, i mean, southerners. I'm glad you enjoyed it !
![]() |
||||
|
|
||||
CaptainThornton |
#2 | |||
|
Welcome Back HistoryBuff,
Glad you had a great time! I would say from the sound of your report that the re-enacting bug has bitten you big time Good to see and welcome to the Brotherhood! Regard, Cap'n PS MoInfantry, As for Miss CC..... WHile she is unquestionably a SOuthern Girl (georgraphically speaking) her loyalties are and will undoubtably remain Blue (LOL Try as I may to make that "Bonnie Blue" |
||||
|
|
||||
HistoryBuff |
#3 | |||
moinfantry wrote: The Tyrant Lincoln forced me to fight for those criminals, I didn't choose to. I may have been wearing blue but I bled GRAY! OK that sounded more impressive in my head, lol. CaptainThornton wrote: Thanks! Yep, it definitely has. It'll take me awhile to recuperate from all that marching and lugging that heavy rifle around, but as soon as I do I'll be lookin' for the next opportunity to do it all over again. It's like a drug! LOL! |
||||
|
|
||||
kelly1863 |
#4 | |||
|
Recuperate fast!! Olustee is in two weeks...
|
||||
|
|
||||
10TnVI |
#5 | |||
|
In sonorus voice
COME YOUNG APPRENTICE-GIVE YOURSELF TO THE DARK BLUE SIDE- IT's a lot more fun and you meet a better class of people;-)
Leland Hares, 10TVI(US)
"and what is war but a dark and desperate game where lives and limbs and hearts and souls of men are staked for knaves"- Sgt. G.W. Squier Semper In Excretum-Sed sole profundum variat |
||||
|
|
||||
HistoryBuff |
#6 | |||
kelly1863 wrote: I got Mt. Dora before that |
||||
|
|
||||
keeno2 |
#7 | |||
|
And that's a big part of reenacting, HistoryBuff. Suffer. It ought to impart a bit of what they went through. I've been a student of the CW for a very
long time, but never did it occur to me that to sleep on the ground with one blanket was something enhancing. Different strokes.
I don't know how they did that, but I am quite content with imagining it. You get to know it. I'll pass on that experience. Wimp Ken
I never knew a man who wished to be himself a slave. Consider if you know any good thing that no man wishes for himself. A. Lincoln
|
||||
|
|
||||
HistoryBuff |
#8 | |||
keeno2 wrote:Yeah, I know. That's the debate going on in my head; realism vs. practicality |
||||
|
|
||||
CaptainThornton |
#9 | |||
|
As a 25 year veteran re-enactor who has served from a private in the ranks to commanding officer on the field, my experiances in re-enacting have been varied
and interesting to say the least. I have spent time in barracks, garrison encampments and campaign style encampments as well. Everyone has their own
preferences but everyone should try them all at least once if for no other reason then to share in the experiance that they, the soliders went through so long
ago.
I will admit as an officer, I do enjoy the comforts of my cot and tent and a good comfortable campaign chair but I still find that taking things to the other end of comfort for the sake of the hobby is still worth the time invested and the experiance gained. One of my most rewarding endeavors included a 17 mile march and night bivowac with only what we carried on our backs i.e. blanket role and some hard tack. Comfort was not even remotely in the picture however, the experiance was something I will always have and cherish. I strongly encourage all who re-enact to at least go the full route and either camp in a garrison style encampment or if your up to it explore the rigors of campaigning it. Something to be said about the aspects of camp life and the experiance gained in the process. For some it is seldom relaized opting to do the motel thing and then show up on the field, resplended uniform, freshly shaved, showered and a Waffle house Breckfast under your belt, While it may be an ends to a means for some, personally I think if you want to be a re-enactor your selling yourself short unless you opt to take on the role in the fullest of your abilities. I realize we all have our own limits and designs. But if you care about history, care about relizing what it was they faced and dealt with on a daily basis, the aspects of getting dirty, loosing some sleep and overexerting yourself for a short weekend is something well worth the effort Something you'll never be sorry to did Regard, Cap'n
Last Edited By: CaptainThornton 01/20/09 15:35:02.
Edited 1 time.
|
||||
|
|
||||
HistoryBuff |
#10 | |||
|
Keeno posted this over in the thread "How big a role did Slavery have in causing the war":
keeno2 wrote:It was the Brooksville Raid, at the Sand Hill Scout Reservation in Spring Hill, FL. I was reenacting with the 5th FL, Co. I of the 3rd Battalion, Hardy's Brigade, but since we had to play Federals they changed their name to the 7th Michigan. I wrote their commanding officer, Lt. Col. Robert Niepert, a few days before the event and asked if it would be OK if I fell in with their group to try out reenacting. He replied almost immediately and was very encouraging and enthusiastic. I'm very impressed with the members of this unit in General and especially Lt. Col. Niepert. He definately has a passion for history, and it reflects in his leadership of the 5th Fl. I drove over on Friday, but unfortunately I locked my keys inside my truck while registering ( After running low on cartridges and caps following the first engagement, I decided that was the first purchase I should make. Plus, I just like things that go boom My favorite part was "dying" during the battle on sunday. After all that marching, I enjoyed the rest |
||||
|
|
||||
keeno2 |
#11 | |||
I drove over on Friday, but unfortunately I locked my keys inside my truck while registeringI can match you bonehead for bonehead and raise you one. Some years ago, a close friend and I thought it might be a good idea to go to a cubbies game and party later. We went in separate cars. After the game, we went to his. No go, he had exited the vehicle and left it running. It had no gas. So we walk several blocks to mine and find that I had left the lights on. No partying that night. Thanks for the expansion on the experience. I make it a point to attend reenactments as an observer. I can absorb a bit of the enthusiasm these guys put into their personnas. Sans camper and AC, I choose to forego the experience. By the way, have you read about the 73 year-old reenactor at an event near, I think, Norfolk, VA? Admirable. But he got shot by a live round fired my some moron. Seems the moron was a walk-in -- not affiliated. Carried a Colt .44. "I didn't know it was loaded!" Darwin will get him eventually. Ken
I never knew a man who wished to be himself a slave. Consider if you know any good thing that no man wishes for himself. A. Lincoln
|
||||
|
|
||||
HistoryBuff |
#12 | |||
keeno2 wrote: Yeah, I heard of that. There were a couple of people like that at the Brooksville Raid, and when called out on their stupidity they back talked and made excuses. I really don't understand some people. |
||||
|
|
||||
10TnVI |
#13 | |||
|
History buff- go ahead and sleep out in the cold(I'll be doing it this weekend in subfreezing nighttime tempetures and I'm 50 years old) it won't
kill you(with proper percautions) and will let you feel what they suffered routinely. When you're back home infront of the heater drinking a beer on Sunday
you will better appreciate the sacrifices they made. Besides, sticking it out when others run for a hotel or don't show up gives you bragging rights
later:-) I still fondly remember shivering under a couple of substandard blankets one night on a ridge in Land between the Lakes. 22 degrees with a breeze that
night, head to the fire and quite warm, toes barely above frozen. Nothing like a 50 degree tempeture difference over 5 feet of distance. Standing picket(Yes,
at some events it's routine) in the dark of a cold night with no one else in sight, just praying your relief will show soon is a expeirence not to be
missed.
Ken- one better-at a 3 day campaign event, again at Land between the Lakes(look it up, 50000 acres of rough hilly woods with no towns or settlements) I changed clothes, stuck my keys in my sneakers(planning to leave them in the bed of the truck), and put on my kit. Then, for some inexplicable reason I stuck those shoes in the cab and locked it, forgetting all about the keys until I went looking for then Sunday afternoon. Panic of course insued until I realized they were in the cab. Then a new panic, since most of the people had already left, the nearest possible phone was a good seven miles away and the nearest town(Dover, Tn) about 30 and what were the chances they'ed have a locksmith on duty Sunday afternoon. Fortunatly one of the officers had the knowledge to break in to my truck(The old coathanger trick doesn't work well on modern vehicles with tight fitting doors and smooth lock post) and the day was saved.
Leland Hares, 10TVI(US)
"and what is war but a dark and desperate game where lives and limbs and hearts and souls of men are staked for knaves"- Sgt. G.W. Squier Semper In Excretum-Sed sole profundum variat |
||||
|
|
||||
HistoryBuff |
#14 | |||
10TnVI wrote:Don't drink beer, lol. I do plan to keep on camping out, though. Already paid for the tent |
||||
|
|
||||
Tar Heel |
#15 | |||
|
Glad you enjoyed the Brooksville Raid. I've been going to that event for over 20 years. And, I, (along with my dad who is the overall re-enactor
coordinator for the event) have just written a book on the event. It is called _"A Heinous Sin": the 1864 Brooksville-Bayport Raid._ One other plug -
if you want a copy of the book, check out my web page: www.michaelchardy.com, or, at Mt. Dora this weekend, find my dad - he is the overall re-enactor
coordinator for that event also (and Crystal River in a few weeks).
Did you get a chance to participate in the Saturday morning battle? It was based on the actual raid. The raid itself was more or less a three day hit and run skirmish from Anclote River up to Bayport. And surprisingly, even though it is known as the Brooksville Raid, the Federals never actually went to Brooksville. A mile from town, they chose to turn off and head to Bayport. In doing so, they pass the opportunity to capture the cannons from Bayport, and destroy a shoe-making operation. Regards, Tar Heel |
||||
|
|
||||
10TnVI |
#16 | |||
|
Hey HB-are you the Vince who posted over on the CW Reenactors webboard asking about rifles?
If you are- the normal combat load for a CW infantry man was 60 Rds-40 in his cartridge box and 20 in his pockets or knapsack. Foe most reenactments I keep 40 in the box and usually about a hundred extra in the knapsack if I'm going to be away from access to my vehicle or stored in my truck if it's reachable. A lot depends on just what sort of reenactment it is, I once carried almost 300 rds in my knapsack to a big multi-day smokefest, but only shot up about 150:-)
Leland Hares, 10TVI(US)
"and what is war but a dark and desperate game where lives and limbs and hearts and souls of men are staked for knaves"- Sgt. G.W. Squier Semper In Excretum-Sed sole profundum variat |
||||
|
|
||||
HistoryBuff |
#17 | |||
10TnVI wrote:Yep, I am. Thanks for the info. Tar Heel wrote:Sorry, I didn't see your post before now. Been down with the flu. I'll check out that book. Will y'all be selling it at Crystal River? |
||||
|
|
||||
Pvtclark |
#18 | |||
|
There is nothing like bacon & eggs cooked on an open fire in the morning. That alone is worth reenacting. At least from a Confederate stand point.
|
||||
|
|
||||
Ron |
#19 | |||
keeno2 wrote:Ken; I can't tell you of the times I have asked myself the question "How did they do that". I still and always will admire what they did, suffer and put up with. This applies to both sides. I'm really going out a limb here and make a statement that"Without the enlisted men, there would NOT have been a civil war". How is that for a bit of philosophy? Ron |
||||
|
|
||||
Pvtclark |
#20 | |||
|
Going out on a limb here "Without the enlisted man there wouldn't have been a civil war"
I have one line of family from western Tenn. who decided not to get involved in the civil war. This didn't last too long, they were draged into it when their farm was raided and all their livestock was stolen about the 3rd time. My gr gr grandfather observed this from a hill near his farm where he hid his family. He was seen and shot in the hip. He survived to write a auto biography but was severly crippled. Not everyone wanted war but some had to fight or die. |
||||
|
|
||||
|
All Rights Reserved. The American Civil War 1861 - 1865 Civil War Message Board, Discussion Group, Civil War Trivia, Civil War Books, Causes of the Civil War, War Between the States, American Civil War
|